September 24, 2007

Throwing Legal Immigrants from the Train

According to this morning's CQ Today (subscription required), the National Council of La Raza, the nation’s largest Latino civil rights organization, dropped its support for the state Children's Health Insurance Program (SCHIP) bill on Friday. Apparently, a last minute addition to the bill forbade enrolling the children of legal immigrants in the program. “We’re going to urge all lawmakers to vote against the bill,” a spokesman for the group told the publication.

The Democrats are scrambling to come up with a veto-proof majority to pass the Senate version of SCHIP, which would expand the number of children covered to 10 million from 6 million, and make cigarette smokers pay for it. Some moderate Republicans want to support the bill, and are even willing to go against the president, but they are also under pressure from the anti-immigration forces that are playing an ever larger role inside the GOP.

This is Washington politics at its despicable worst, not to mention gross discrimination against foreigners who are here legally. The Democrats who okayed this provision to win a few more votes should be ashamed of themselves.

I will never forget while I was living in Japan when I needed to use their health care system on an emergency basis. No questions were asked and no fees were collected. I'll never forget what it was like to live in a civilized country.

Posted by gooznews at September 24, 2007 08:50 AM
Comments

It is more like throw legal and illegal immigrants under the train. Unfortunately, the problem in the USA far outstrips the problems in an island nation like Japan. Japan civilized? Dont be so certain 90% of police arrests result in criminal prosecution since the police are believed to be infallible. Civility can hide tremendous injustice and inhumanity.

Posted by: sam at September 25, 2007 07:52 AM


The problem with healthcare is not that doctors or patients are doing something wrong. the problem has to do with human nature. we live in a free society so government mandated programs will never be well accepted. even if they are, medicare for example, there is widespread fraud there is a lot of waste. even so, i believe in a free society, so free care should only be provided to those who fall below the poverty line.

Posted by: robert rodriguez M.D. at October 8, 2007 04:55 PM