After weeks of leaking elements of the administration plans for health care system change, President Obama today outlined a path to guaranteed universal insurance coverage that would entail some cost controls, some tax increases, and the beginning of a movement to improve the quality and efficiency of the way the medical profession delivers care.
You can read the full-text of the president's speech to the American Medical Association here. A few random thoughts:
Favorite quotes:
"If we do not fix our health care system, America may go the way of GM -- paying more, getting less, and going broke."
And:
"And if we're honest, another part of the reason (reform has failed in the past) has been the fierce opposition fueled by some interest groups and lobbyists -- opposition that has used fear tactics to paint any effort to achieve reform as an attempt to, yes, socialize medicine."
Most inaccurate statement:
"You (the AMA) promised to work together to cut national health care spending by $2 trillion over the next decade, relative to what it would have otherwise been. And that will bring down costs; that will bring down premiums. That's exactly the kind of cooperation we need, and we appreciate that very much. Thank you." (Applause.)
That's inaccurate because the pledge by health care providers to reduce spending by $200 billion a year over the next decade will reduce spending to about 1 1/2 percentage points faster than GDP growth. That will cut the growth rate relative to GDP in half, but that isn't going to "bring down costs" or "bring down premiums." Health care costs will continue to rise as a share of GDP and continue to take a growing share of income, just not as fast as before.
The most significant part of his speech, however, focused on costs. Indeed, after reciting the laundry list of pet issues for some reformers: higher quality through use of electronic medical records; more attention to preventive care and health promotion; he turned to what he saw as the underlying driver of rising health care costs:
"What accounts for the bulk of our costs is the nature of our health care delivery system itself -- a system where we spend vast amounts of money on things that aren't necessarily making our people any healthier; a system that automatically equates more expensive care with better care."
How to tackle that problem? The administration will back these reforms in the Medicare section of the health care reform bill: bundling payments for chronic diseases like diabetes; incentives to get doctors working together in teams; bonuses for better outcomes; comparative effectiveness research (to provide information, not tell doctors what to do); and incentivizing physicians and hospitals to use those best practices.
Then the president turned to the most controversial elements of his reform proposal:
"The public option is not your enemy, it is your friend," he said.
How would the president pay for the $1 trillion that his plan will cost over the next decade? By raising taxes on the well-off, ending Medicare Advantage's excess payments, and generating $313 billion in Medicare and Medicaid savings by reducing hospital payments, drug company payments and introducing generic versions of biologic drugs (Obama specifically mentioned the drug for treating anemia, which has been the subject of many posts on this website).
The president has surrounded himself with some of the smartest health policy thinkers in the nation. He has familiarized himself with the issues. Today, he was a forceful and effective spokesman for change.
However, there are plenty of landmines on the road to reform. The hospitals, insurance companies, drug and biotech companies, and specialty physicians are being asked to take serious haircuts. Tying repeal of the Bush tax cut for the wealthy to health care reform is much better than taxing health benefits, but isn't a slam dunk. At least one special interest group -- the radiologists and the various imaging machine makers -- has already declared war on efforts to rein in their costs.
The president's oratorical skills were impressive. But at the end of the day, it will be his team's political skills on Capitol Hill that will matter most.
Comments
Well, I think all of us has
Well, I think all of us has to read about the state of economy! The health care benefits that gives us the chance to save money in its cheapest offer in medication.A lot of people are quite vocal opponents of socialized medicine, and it isn't without merit. There is an online petition going around at freeourhealthcarenow.com, which seeks to petition President Obama not to put forth any measures whatsoever for universal health care, and a lot of people would give an instant payday loan to make certain of it. It's a tricky issue – the Veterans Administration is public funded health care – as many feel that private insurance and play or pay is the way to go. HMO CEOs getting rich is a national priority, certainly more so than our children, which is why it's worth an online cash advance to steer clear of socialized medicine.
U.S. for-profit health care
I'm so sick and tired of
I'm so sick and tired of hearing about Obama and how "socialized" his health care plan is. The fear mongering and such has gotten me completely sick.
He's trying to do what is absolutely best for this country! Our healthcare system is a complete monopolized P.O.S. that needs fixing now!!!
Yet the far right wingnuts have everyone scared and now they are ruining it for everyone!
Steven
He's trying to do what HE
He's trying to do what HE thinks is best. I'm not saying he's right and I'm not saying he's wrong but he's not willing to listen to anyone but people who agree with him.
Red, yellow, black and white maybe equal in His sight but if you disagree with him your an misinformed idiot. LOL
Dang Rabbit